Question 1

Can my landlord charge me for a broken window?

Accepted Answer

Yes, if you broke the window through negligence, misuse, or an accident caused by your actions. However, landlords cannot charge for windows broken by outside forces (weather, third parties), pre-existing cracks or damage, or normal aging of old window frames. The charge must also be prorated based on the window's age.

Question 2

What if the window was already cracked when I moved in?

Accepted Answer

If the window was cracked or damaged at move-in and you documented this on your move-in checklist (or in photos), you cannot be charged for that damage. This is why move-in documentation is critical. If you didn't document it, the landlord may try to charge you for pre-existing damage.

Question 3

Can a landlord charge for a cracked window from temperature changes?

Accepted Answer

Windows that crack due to thermal stress (temperature changes) or settling of the building are generally the landlord's responsibility to repair — not the tenant's. This type of cracking is considered a building maintenance issue, not tenant damage. However, the landlord may dispute whether the crack was caused by temperature or impact.

Question 4

How much can a landlord charge for a broken window?

Accepted Answer

The charge should reflect the actual cost of repair or replacement, prorated for the window's age. Glass replacement for a standard window typically costs $150-400. Full window frame replacement can cost $300-800+. The landlord must get the least expensive adequate repair, not automatically replace the entire window unit if only the glass is broken.

Can a Landlord Charge for a Broken Window?